We were told our daughters didn’t suffer in the Hillsborough disaster - their death records must be corrected
Sarah and Victoria Hicks were among the 97 Liverpool supporters unlawfully killed in the disaster.
The parents of two teenage sisters who were killed in the Hillsborough disaster have launched a fresh legal effort to correct the official court record, which suggests their daughters didn’t suffer.
Sarah and Victoria Hicks were among the 97 Liverpool supporters unlawfully killed at Hillsborough on April 15, 1989.
Their parents, Jenni and Trevor Hicks, are seeking formal recognition that their daughters did not lose consciousness within 30 seconds and die shortly thereafter, but suffered for significantly longer.


Jenni Hicks, from Liverpool, said: “For more than three decades, the law has recorded something about our daughters that we now know simply isn’t true.
“This isn’t about compensation. It’s about truth. It’s about dignity. And it’s about acknowledging what Sarah and Vicki — and so many others — went through that devastating day.”
“This is not just about correcting it for our beautiful daughters, it’s for everyone who died that day, and for other families that find themselves facing similar injustices and incorrect legal records.”
The record cannot be officially corrected without the consent of South Yorkshire Police (SYP), which Jenni and her former husband Trevor say they have not received so far.
The chief constable of SYP, Lauren Poultney, has said the force “will take the steps available to us to support the families”.


The “30-second rule” was relied upon in civil litigation following Hillsborough to argue that victims lost consciousness almost immediately and therefore didn’t suffer.
In the early 1990s, Jenni Hicks and Trevor Hicks brought a test case against South Yorkshire Police for the pain and suffering their daughters endured before their deaths.
The case was dismissed on the basis that the girls were assumed to have lost consciousness almost immediately.
Sarah and Victoria, the courts held, had experienced “swift and sudden [deaths] as shown by the medical evidence.”
- Get the biggest stories from Merseyside in your inbox with Liverpool World’s free newsletter emails.
That stands as a public record – but the Hillsborough Independent Panel (2012) and the fresh Hillsborough inquests (2014 – 2016) have since stated that this assumption was flawed, with the sisters believed to have survived for up to an hour after the crush started.
Victoria, aged 15, was the only female child victim of the crush. Multiple witnesses reported that she was crying and in distress for some time.
Sarah, aged 19, was seen by numerous witnesses who described her as intensely distressed and panicked about the fate of her younger sister.
Now, Jenni and Trevor are calling for a ‘Hicks’ Rule’ to be introduced so that people in similar circumstances are able to easily correct the official legal record, where necessary, in future.
Trevor Hicks, from Settle, North Yorkshire said: “The injustice here is not abstract.


“Because the courts accepted the police version of events, we were told our daughters didn’t suffer. We were told the law could do nothing more for them. That was wrong then, and it’s wrong now.”
The legal effort follows an out of court settlement with South Yorkshire Police relating to historic claims brought by the family.
Trevor added: “The money is irrelevant. The key thing we want is the court records corrected.”
This evening (Monday, February 9), the Hicks family will address a parliamentary event in Westminster to examine how the law can correct historic judicial records where later evidence has fundamentally overturned the facts on which those decisions were based.
Caoilfhionn Gallagher KC, lead counsel for Jenni and Trevor Hicks, says the case raises issues that go far beyond Hillsborough.
“This is about whether the legal system has the courage and the mechanisms to correct itself when later evidence proves earlier assumptions to be false,” she said.
“The findings of the Hillsborough Independent Panel and the fresh inquests are unequivocal. This was not a ‘swift and sudden death’ for Sarah and Victoria — far from it. For an agonising hour they suffered prolonged pain and suffering. And yet the formal legal record remains unchanged.
“That cannot be right and we are determined to set the record straight. I believe a Hicks’ Rule laid down in law will make it easier for families facing similar battles in future.”
