placeholder image
Getty Images

Everton player ratings vs Newcastle: 'Absolute clanger' among lots of 4/10s and just one 6/10 in 4-1 loss

Everton player ratings and scored from the 4-1 defeat by Newcastle United in the Premier League at Hill Dickinson Stadium.

Everton delivered their worst performance of the season as they sank to a 4-1 loss at the hands of Newcastle United at Hill Dickinson Stadium.

The Toffees conceded three goals before half-time which proved their downfall before falling further behind inside an hour. And despite Kiernan Dewsbury-Hall bagging a consolation goal, David Moyes would have been seething at the display that arrived after his side secured a deserved 1-0 win at Manchester United despite having 10 men.

Everton vs Newcastle match report

Everton were caught sleeping at the start of the game, with Jordan Pickford forced to keep out a save from Anthony Elanga within 20 seconds. And from the subsequent corner, Newcastle took the lead when Malick Thiaw powered home a header.

While Everton responded somewhat, they failed to test Aaron Ramsdale in the visitors’ goal. And on 25 minutes, Toffees keeper Pickford made a horrendous blunder when Lewis Miley’s shot went through him to double the Magpies’ advantage.

Then on the stroke of half-time, Newcastle put the game to rest. Tim Iroegbunam misjudged a bouncing ball which allowed Elanga through and he found Nick Woltemade, who displayed fine composure to lob the onrushing Pickford.

Everton were playing for pride in the second half and on 53 minutes, James Garner’s inswinging corner was just kept out by Ramsdale before substitute Charly Alcaraz rattled the crossbar with the rebound.

But in the 58th minute, Newcastle ensured there would be no Blues comeback when Thiaw was left unmarked at the back post and headed home his second of the encounter.

Thierno Barry thought he’d finally broken his Everton goal duck when he found the back of the net six minutes later, but a VAR review adjudged the striker to have brought the ball down with his hand. The home faithful who remained in the stadium did get something to cheer about on 69 minutes when Kiernan Dewsbury-Hall produced an excellent touch and finish.

Yet that was nothing more than a consolation as the game ultimately fizzled out, with Everton missing out on a chance to record three straight victories.

Everton player ratings vs Newcastle

Follow us
© 2026 Iconic Media Group Ltd. All rights reserved.Cookie SettingsTerms and ConditionsPrivacy notice