Liverpool ensured they did not suffer a shock upset at the start of their Carabao Cup defence as they edged past Derby County on penalties.
The Reds were held to a goalless draw after 90 minutes before winning the shootout 3-2 to move into the fourth round.
The first half was a dull affair, with neither side creating any clear-cut chances. Alex Oxlade-Chamberlain fizzed a volley not too far wide before Layton Stewart hooked an effort over the crossbar.
Liverpool played virtually the entire second half in Derby’s half. Klopp called in the cavalry when he made a triple substitution to bring on Darwin Nunez, Roberto Firmino and Harvey Elliott.
And it was Elliott who went agonisingly close to breaking the deadlock when his deft touch was saved by Wildsmith.
Yet Liverpool could not find a breakthrough and the League One visitors held out for penalties.
And keeper Caoimhin Kelleher made three huge saves before Elliott stepped up to stroke home the winning spot-kick.
Here’s how we rated the Liverpool players.

9. Melkamu Fraunendorf - 6
Struggled to get into the game in the opening 45 minutes. More involved in the second half, sending in one cross that Carvalho couldn’t meet. Subbed in the 61st minute. | Liverpool FC via Getty Images Photo: Andrew Powell/Liverpool FC via Getty Images

10. Fabio Carvalho - 5
A couple of nice touches in the first half but didn’t provide the quality required. One shot saved in the second half but a subdued evening overall before being subbed in the 74th minute. | Liverpool FC via Getty Images Photo: Andrew Powell/Liverpool FC via Getty Images

11. Layton Stewart - 6
Not involved too much but did win the ball back before having one chance on goal in the first half which he put over. Subbed in the 61st minute. | AFP via Getty Images Photo: OLI SCARFF/AFP via Getty Images

12. Sub 1 - Roberto Firmino - 6
Pepped Liverpool up off the bench and had a solid header saved. Then sent his penalty into orbit. | Liverpool FC via Getty Images Photo: Andrew Powell/Liverpool FC via Getty Images


